What is the difference between roof heat proofing and roof insulation? Which do I need?
During the summer we often get a call. Someone has had their roof heat proofed (either with a coating or chip layer) but still can’t stand being on the top floor. Or someone is looking to spend some cash and got a quote for heat proofing from one tradesman and another for insulation from another. They just can’t tell the difference. Often people use the terms interchangeably. This can be a costly learning curve!
Understanding the problem
There are two causes of hot roofs. First, when your roof is hit by the sun the radiation hits the roof and heats it up. Then heat transfer takes place via conduction through the slab/sheet into your room. Whatever roof solution you use will be trying to address one or both issues.
What is roof heat proofing?
In Pakistan heat proofing is a general term and can be any of the following:
- Reflective coatings/cool roof paints – Light colours or reflective surfaces to reject some of the solar radiation.
- Chip/mosaic – White cracked tiles or similar laid on top of waterproofing to reflect heat.
- Lightweight Screeds – Foam bead or similar lightweight materials added (often have a local brand name). Add a small amount of resistance.
All of these are primarily to keep your roof cool. Some also add a small amount of resistance to heat transfer.
What is roof insulation?
This addresses the second issue. Insulation is a material with very low thermal conductivity (rockwool boards, XPS, PU or PIR boards, EPS). These are installed on top or underneath the slab/sheet. Whatever the temperature on the roof surface it will slow down the heat coming into your building. How effective it is will depend on the material and the thickness. You can compare different products based on their data sheets. With correct insulation your roof will be much cooler inside.
Difference
| Heat Proofing (Coating/Chips) | Insulation | |
|---|---|---|
| Main action | Reflects the sun to reduce roof temp | Reduces heat transfer through the roof |
| Room temperature | Limited reduction in room temp | Greater and more reliable |
| Data sheets | Not often comparable with data sheet info | Can be compared with thickness and conductivity |
| Cost | Generally cheaper | Generally more expensive |
| Longevity | Coatings will fade, crack and get dirty | Long lasting if protected and installed correctly |
| Winter benefit | Little or none | Yes – retains heat |
| Best for | Budget/Rental/Quick fix | Air Con / Long term / Factories |
Limitations
Reflective coatings will only work if clean and undamaged. Over time dust, algae, monsoon staining and weathering will reduce the effectiveness. Cracking can cause water ingress. It doesn’t address the heat transfer issue so won’t reduce as much heat that has built up in the slab. This is why your roof can still be hot at night. If it claims to reduce a set amount of degrees you should be cautious. Unless they can provide a test result for your type of roof.
Limitations
Insulation isn’t magic! You need to make sure you have a good waterproofing layer. Wet insulation won’t work. It also needs to be protected from the sun, foot traffic and weather. It needs to be installed with no gaps and sealed around the edges and any penetrations. If it isn’t installed properly you may be disappointed. See our guide to checking your insulation.
Which should I choose?
- Air Con Home/Office – Insulation. This is where your money will go. Insulation will reduce the load on your AC the most.
- Factory/Warehouse (with metal roof) – Insulation (often with a reflective finish). See our commercial roof guide.
- House on rent or on a tight budget – A reflective coating/chip can be a good starting point. Be realistic with your expectations.
- Leaky roof – Fix the waterproofing.
- Cold areas (Murree/Gilgit) – Insulation. It will help in the winter. Heat proofing won’t.
Often the best option is both!
They aren’t enemies. A popular roof build up is waterproofing then insulation. This can then be topped with a protective and reflective finish. This will protect your insulation and reduce the working temperature. Insulation will do the hard work. If you design your roof as a system it will often be cheaper in the long run.
Questions to ask
- What is actually going to be installed and how thick is it?
- Is there a data sheet/test result?
- Is there waterproofing included?
- Who is responsible if the roof leaks?
- What is the warranty?
- What isn’t included?
- Are they working with you if you want solar panels?
FAQ
Is roof heat proofing the same as insulation?
No, heat proofing usually refers to coatings or chips. This reduces the roof surface temperature. Insulation is a layer which reduces the heat transfer.
Does roof cooling paint work?
It can reduce the roof surface temperature however it will usually not be as effective as insulation. It will also lose effectiveness over time.
Which is best to reduce my AC bill?
Insulation is generally a better and longer lasting option. Especially if you have air con. You can add a reflective finish.
Can I do both?
Yes! Often this is the best option. Waterproofing, insulation and protective reflective finish.
Contact Pakistan Insulations today for a free consultation and quote.
Phone: +92-21-34529722
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.pakinsulation.com